| | |

AI steals ideas. If you use it, that becomes your problem.

Among serious writers and thinkers, there is an ethos of giving appropriate credit to the originators of ideas.

Stealing ideas is different from plagiarizing words, which we know is wrong. While you can easily get away stealing ideas at first, you’ll eventually lose respect from others in the community of thinkers. This principle is enforced in academic settings, but is equally important among all the community of people who write online posts, share them on social media, give speeches, and otherwise discuss ideas. Fail to give credit and you’ll soon be a pariah.

While this has always been a problem, AI makes it worse. Use AI for research, writing, or editing and you’re at risk of ripping off other people’s ideas without credit, regardless of whether you intend to do so.

Let’s talk about what it means to cite the creators of ideas and how to adhere to those norms in a world where so many writers use AI to help them.

What is an idea and what does it mean to give credit?

Ideas are elusive things; it’s difficult to talk about them. If I tell you to use salt to clean a cast iron pan, I obviously wasn’t the first to figure that out, but the concept is not based on some well understood framework of ideas. Nobody cares who came up with it.

In general, we consider an idea to belong to someone if they:

  1. Described the justification and details of the idea in detail, as in an article or a book.
  2. Were the first to do so.
  3. Often, invented a unique name for their concept framework.

For example, Clayton Christensen gets credit for the theory of disruption in technology markets. He changed everyone’s thinking with an article and then a book, The Innovator’s Dilemma.

Everett Rogers gets credit for the theory of diffusion of innovation — how technologies are adopted first by early adopters, then by the early majority, and so on. He wasn’t the first to describe this, but his analysis was influential and generated a unified perspective among business thinkers. Later on, Geoffrey Moore built on Rogers’ ideas in his book Crossing the Chasm, which described in detail what it would take to go from attracting early adopters to the early majority.

When an idea like this is relatively new and you want to use it, it pays not only to cite the idea’s creator, but to provide a link to their book or research. This shows that you did your homework. Even if your idea extends or contradicts the original research, you need to give credit.

Once an idea has seen widespread adoption, it’s no longer necessary to cite the original source, but it still makes sense to credit the creator. You can describe Clayton Christensen’s theories of disruption or Geoffrey Moore’s description of crossing the chasm without mentioning their books, both of which were published more than 25 years ago.

At some point, an idea enters the zeitgeist and these restrictions tend to be relaxed. You can use Newton’s invention of calculus without identifying him by name, or Freud’s theory of psychoanalysis without invoking him.

But regardless of how you give credit for an idea, be aware that ignorance is no excuse for ripping people off without credit. Even if you think an idea is original with you, it’s your job to identify who else may have written about it first. “I thought the idea was original with me” and “I never saw that somebody else had written about it,” are the irrelevant protests of someone who is not a serious thinker. How would you feel if the tables were turned and it was your idea being stolen? Web research is easy now, so it’s easy to check if your idea is original.

This came up for me recently when writing about the idea of “ghostediting,” that is editing that verges into rewriting. I observed that AI-generated text often requires it, and had heard the term “ghostediting,” which seemed ideal to describe it. I determined that the editor John Robin had used the term in the way I wanted to in 2025, so I cited his work. Rachel Arterberry also wrote about “ghost editing.” It felt like a new idea to me, but other people got there first, and they deserve credit.

The danger of AI, which is a ripoff machine

You don’t need AI to steal ideas. I observed this a few years ago, when I was ghostwriting a book for some thinkers in a consulting firm. When they provided me with source material for their ideas, I was startled to see concepts I knew were originated by others — because I’d worked closely with the team that had originally developed them! Now that my antennas were up, I researched other ideas in the book carefully and observed that some of them were also were derived from ideas originated by others. My clients had extended and improved the ideas, but the originators deserved credit. Those ideas still made their way into the book, but now with appropriate credit to their originators including web links and book citations.

The problem now is that with AI tools, anyone can now do what those clients did, often without even realizing it.

Large language models are basically tools for hoovering up vast amounts of information and spewing them back out in new forms. Giving credit for ideas is secondary. As a result, if you use AI to generate text or even just to do research, it’s going to find and present other people’s ideas. They may or may not include who originated those ideas — and even if an AI tools provides a citation, you cannot count on those attributions being accurate.

The onus is on you to check, especially if you use these tools.

You can ask an AI tool where an idea came from, and it will usually give you a citation. It’s sometimes helpful to use different tools to check, for example, using Google Search (which is AI-enhanced) or Perplexity to check text generated by Claude or ChatGPT. You can also tell the AI tools you use that they need to provide citations for any ideas they come up with, which will help (but often, the tool won’t recognize the idea or provide the correct citation even with such instructions). Then you need to check the citation to see if it’s accurate.

It’s would be a lot easier to ignore this problem. It’s a lot more fun to focus on ideas and language than who gets credit. But your name is going on the book or whatever content you’re creating. That means you get the blame if you’ve used others’ ideas without appropriate credit. You’ll get a reputation as an idea-stealer and a ripoff artist, and “I used AI” is not a viable excuse. In fact, it’s an indictment of your inability to think originally.

Bottom line: investigate the provenance of your ideas — whether they came out of your own head or an LLM offered them up. That’s what it means to be a responsible member of the community of ideas.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.