|

How to post challenging ideas on social media

I’ve written more than 3,000 blog posts and tens of thousands of social media posts over two-plus decades, mostly about substantive topics in the spaces I was covering.

Here’s what you learn about posting in places where people can respond: How those people respond will tell you how you are doing.

What social media responses and blog comments tell you

  • If you get no interaction, you haven’t said anything interesting. You are not contributing to the conversation.
  • If everyone agrees with you, you still haven’t contributed much. You are just reinforcing the echo chamber and embracing a fan base. Feels good, means nothing.
  • If everyone disagrees with you, you’re probably wrong. If you can’t win anybody over, either your point is wrong or you haven’t been convincing. Your contribution isn’t meaningful. Go back and try again.
  • If people have a variety of reactions, great! The people who agree will often suggest extensions to your reasoning. The people who disagree will show holes in your arguments. And the people who see both sides may show you a new way to look at the problem. Once people start reacting to each others’ arguments, you’ll really learn something.

Farm for discussion, not controversy

It’s easy to provoke people. All it does it make people angry. It generates more heat than light.

It’s not so easy to make people think. But when you do, a discussion breaks out. People learn from each other. You learn from them. You change minds. And they change yours.

Do not be afraid of disagreement. It’s a sign that you’re on the right track . . . and it shows you where that track may go next.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2 Comments

  1. I can think of at least two reasons that a provocative post garners little or no reaction.

    1. The post could be inconveniently timed. For example, I would comment on your blog posts more often if they arrived in my Inbox during work hours, when I’m at my computer. But they usually arrive when I’m eating breakfast and not fully awake. By the time I get to my computer, I’ve forgotten about your post unless I’ve made a reminder to reply, as I did for this one.

    There’s a way to test my theory: If the writer has a global audience, and his post receives no feedback from readers in any time zone, then yes, the post had nothing compelling to say.

    Unless–

    2. The post has made a point that everyone disagrees with or dislikes but no one can refute. For example, I strongly oppose “equal pay for equal work” on principle. You would think that when I explain why in a comment, scores of readers would indignantly reply, eager to expose the fallacy of my argument. But they don’t, because they can’t.

    The same silence greets comments where I explain why it’s irrational to believe that (a) women are systemically paid less for equal work, or (2) Israel has committed genocide. Readers react with downvotes or laughter emojis, but when I point out the cognitive dissonance such a belief requires, they have no words.

    Sometimes, I rub it in their faces by ending my comment, “Those who can, refute. Those who can’t, downvote or react with a laughing emoji.”